Log In
Home
August 7, 2014
Offline
Hi George,
With some delay, but here is your new set of documents.
regards
Michel
October 28, 2022
Offline
George Zaremba said
Michel can you advise when I will receive a revised copy of the workshop drawings for this project ?
Is there anything else I need to do to move this forward ?
I would suggest a good update in the program would be to call the "Tread width", "Going" which is what it is. Tread width is misleading as it is not included the nosing dimension.
Kind regards, George
Hello Michel,
Thank you for the stair file, upon receiving it and reviewing it, I have noticed that I made a big mistake. I don't know what I was thinking but I assumed the going included the nosing and this is absolutely not so. So my going was 303.4 and should have been 273.4 .
I have redrawn from scratch the stairs and attach the corrected version. I am really sorry to create additional work for you.
Kind regards
George
PS. The software is excellent, commendations to the developers and designers
October 28, 2022
Offline
Hello Michel,
Thank you for the stair file, upon receiving it and reviewing it, I have noticed that I made a big mistake. I don't know what I was thinking but I assumed the going included the nosing and this is absolutely not so. So my going was 303.4 and should have been 273.4 .
I have redrawn from scratch the stairs and attach the corrected version. I am really sorry to create additional work for you.
Kind regards
George
PS. The software is excellent, commendations to the developers and designers
August 7, 2014
Offline
Hi George,
Here is your stairfile
Regards
Michel
October 28, 2022
Offline
Hi Michel,
Thanks for the updated version. I confirm that everything that the length of the stairs are correct. A final short step will be added on the landing to take the 56mm into account, I could not see how you would do this in the application.
KR
George
August 7, 2014
Offline
Hi George,
you have to upgrade to the latest version
https://drive.google.com/file/.....sp=sharing
so you mean that the last step should be inside the 5158.2? If so it needs to be changed
regards
Michel
October 28, 2022
Offline
Hi Michel,
The length is correct as in the PNG file you have sent me. When I try to open the V2 file I get an error message, I have included a PNG showing the error. Can you advise?
August 7, 2014
Offline
Hi George,
You added on the wrong side of the riser. I corrected it myself. I just noticed that you did not add a landing step, but you extended the stringboards beyond the last step by 56mm. The smallest step in this setup is 60mm. In case you will have to reduce it upon production. This setup also means that the last step is not included in the flight length. So now, in fact, the total length of your stair is 5158.2 + 56 mm. If this is correct, please confirm otherwise, you need to correct this.
I attached the version with the correction on the risers. You always have to look in your 3D window in wireframe to see if a change has been done properly.
regards
Michel
October 28, 2022
Offline
Hello Michel,
Thank you for your review. I have revised the drawing to implement your suggestions and attached a revised version.
If you can just check the revisions to ensure I have understood you correctly. Thank you for your advice.
Kind regards
George
August 7, 2014
Offline
Hi George,
Ok, it worked now. Everything looks fine. I only have a few remarks before sending the documents, as you have to be sure.
1 I do not see any penetration value from the riser to the lower side of the steps. It is usually 10mm.
2 the steps only penetrate the newel 5mm as it should normally have the same value as in the stringboards.
3 steps have an upper recess to the stringboards of 5mm. I would advise the same in the newels.
The stair as drawn is possible. I want to make you aware of what I found when checking. Point 1 is the most disturbing to me.
Regards
Michel
October 28, 2022
Offline
Hello Michel,
I have shortened the filename.
KR George
August 7, 2014
Offline
Hi George,
no, it is not working. It needs to be a .stair file extension. Please shorten the name as this is very long for a stairfile name
also, look at this post to see if you doing it correctly
https://wooddesigner.org/forum.....ing-files/
regards
Michel
October 28, 2022
Offline
Hello Michel,
I don't understand as it loads fine on my pc. I will try again, if for some reason it does not work can you email me and I will email you the file.
Thanks
George
1 Guest(s)
Usage Policy